How We Test and Review Online Casinos

NZCasinoClub provides objective, unbiased, data-driven online casino reviews with the aim of providing customers with a reference point when making their gaming-related decisions. We aim to inform thousands of players each day about the available gaming opportunities. 

Our teams strive to provide accurate, reliable and up-to-date information to players. We are aware of the dynamics of this industry as well as the hundreds of service providers. It is our goal to provide leadership and quality information to enable players to make the right decisions. Join us as we explore the process and strategies we employ to bring you accurate information.

Review Frequency and Data Collection

NZCasinoClub released its first online casino review in 2020. It has been consistent in releasing reviews ever since, as the numbers of casinos online continue to go up. Currently, we are reviewing an average of 10 online casinos each month. Our team of experts has been correcting and analysing data from over 30 sites with each review. Therefore, our readers get comprehensive, factual information on each site we review.

Monthly Review Metrics

Our monthly calendar is usually full, with about 15 research entries scheduled to be completed. We also test about 20 offers each month. Additionally, our team reviews about 25 data points and industry statistics to provide our readers with expert opinions and ratings that are in line with the current industry trends.

All these culminate in online casino reviews that we post on our website:

  • Pros
    15 research entries
  • Pros
    20 tested offers
  • Pros
    25 data points and industry statistics each month
  • Pros
    10 online casino reviews each month

Accuracy and Error Rates

We strive to provide factual, verifiable information. That is why we do in-depth research in all our reviews. You can expect a few errors in one or two reviews. We have very low error rates, with the annual average standing at a mere 4.9%. Our team is improving research strategies and expects to lower the annual error rate by about 0.6% every 6 months. We also do a monthly review and update the processed data to achieve high accuracy levels.

Research and Analysis Methodology

NZCasinoClub online casino reviews are based on solid industry knowledge and in-depth research.

We also collect hard data in the following areas:

  1. Casino Software Development We analyse encryption types and random number generators (RNG) for each website we review.
  2. Legal StructuresOur team has an in-depth understanding of gambling laws, taxes, and licencing requirements in most countries.
  3. Industry Trends We monitor trends such as popular casino games, payment services, and average betting limits.
  4. Company UpdatesWe keep track of casino-owning companies and their developments. Our team then evaluates the impact on their casinos.
  5. Game Knowledge We research and get updated on the technical knowledge of game rules, types, and strategies.
  6. Live Dealer and Support Standards We evaluate live dealer conduct across various providers and rate the quality of customer support.

We also make a 100% comparison of reviewed operators with their competitors and industry benchmarks. This helps our readers determine if the operator is worth their time or if there are better ones out there.

Customer Feedback and Reports

We believe that customers who have played the said games or at the specified casino have first-hand information about their experience. Our teams include customer feedback in the overall review results to ensure comprehensive insights. We currently have a huge customer review database. The 2025 NZCasinoClub database includes over 200 customer reports and reviews that we incorporate in our review articles.

Specific Evaluation Criteria

We do in-depth research on all casinos that we review to ensure that they meet the set standards across all their features.

Our teams employ a rigorous testing process that includes the following areas:

  • Licencing and Regulation

    Licencing and Regulation

     The casino that makes our list must have obtained an operating licence from a reputable gaming authority. Once we find the licence details, we verify them to determine if it is indeed valid and come from purportedly reputable regulatory bodies. This ensures that there are no rogue operators that make it to our website.

    Licenced casinos operate lawfully within set boundaries, as spelt out in the regulations. These regulations protect players and there is an external body that listens to disputes or issues that the casino is unable to resolve conclusively.

    Some of the top gaming watchdogs that we look at include the following:

    • Malta Gaming Authority (MGA)
    • The United Kingdom Gambling Commission (UKGC)
    • Gibraltar Regulatory Authority (GRA)
    • Alderney Gambling Control Commission (AGCC)
    • Isle of Man Gambling Supervision Commission (GSC)
  • Security

    Security

    We also assess security measures such as SSL encryption and data protection policies. SSL encryption ensures all data that moves between the user’s device and casino servers is coded in a way that third parties cannot intercept and understand it. We also check the casino’s data protection policies in a bid to ensure that customer data and their money are safe in the hands of the operator.

  • Casino Reputation

    Casino Reputation

    Our team does background checks on the casino's history, ownership, and management. We look for the consistency, reliability and robust reputation of the casino operating company. Additionally, we analyse player feedback as posted on various platforms. This way, we get a whole picture of the casino’s past and present.

  • Game Selection and Software

    Game Selection and Software

    We also evaluate game variety, software providers, and game fairness (RTP percentages). It is our belief that casinos with a huge casino library and diverse games provide an all-around experience that satisfies different customer preferences. Besides, the presence of leading and reputable software is a mark of reliability for players. Finally, the RTP provides the average earning potential, especially for players who play for extended periods.

  • Bonuses and Promotions

    Bonuses and Promotions

    We also analyse the welcome bonuses, on-going promotions, and fairness of bonus terms. NZCasinoClub values casinos that provide their players with several bonuses on the site and have reasonable terms and conditions. When it comes to bonus terms and conditions, we check the wagering terms, validity, allowed games, and game contributions.

    Our team is also keen to highlight negative terms like withdrawal caps, high wagering requirements and limits on the payment methods to use to make qualifying deposits. Our team also prioritises casinos that have various bonuses on the promotions page, like no deposit bonus offers, cashback promotions, free spins and reload bonuses, among others.

  • Payment Methods

    Payment Methods

    We review deposit and withdrawal options, transaction speed, fees, and currency support. An ideal casino should provide players with smooth and efficient ways to transact with their accounts. This includes the inclusion of diverse payment methods that work in areas where it has a presence.

    As a bare minimum, we expect the casino to provide traditional card options, e-wallets like Neteller and Skrill, mobile pay wallets like Google Pay and prepaid cards. Additionally, as cryptocurrencies become increasingly popular, we would love to highlight casinos that accept them.

    In the same spirit, we check the processing times for these methods. We are also keen to note if there are any charges or added costs for transferring cash between the user and casino accounts.

  • Customer Support

    Customer Support

    NZCasinoClub also evaluates customer support availability, responsiveness, and quality. We check the number of ways players at the selected casino can reach out to customer service as well as the average time it takes to have a response. Some of the popular help options include email, live chat, phone and the FAQ page. We also appreciate casinos that are available on social media platforms. Additionally, our review team checks if the customer support team is articulate and customer-friendly.

  • Responsible Gambling

    Responsible Gambling

    Gambling is inherently addictive and some players may lose control of their behaviour. Reputable casinos provide them with tools to help them control their gambling and manage both time and money. Therefore, we check the availability of responsible gambling tools and support for problem gamblers. Some of the options we look at include money, time and wager limits, self-exclusion, and links to help centres.

Workflow and Resource Allocation

NZCasinoClub has put in place various teams and a budget to ensure that critical timelines are met effectively.

Here is how we do it:

Team Composition

We have a team of two NZCasinoClub experts that create between 8 and 10 online casino reviews each month. They follow the methodology discussed below to ensure each of the critical areas of a casino is researched conclusively.

Workflow Process

A research team of two people investigates a casino’s reputation, security, software, licences, certifications, and owning company. Then, an author creates a review based on the data gathered by our researchers.

Once the article is complete, an editing team made up of two senior editors checks the accuracy and relevance of the review. Finally, our main editor, Robert Longthorpe, checks and approves the review before publication on NZCasinoClub.com.

Time and Financial Investment

We invest the following in time and money to ensure that the work is done conclusively:

  • Pros
    Monthly Time Investment
  • Pros
    Research: 90 hours.
  • Pros
    Website Testing and Data Collection: 90 hours.
  • Pros
    Data Analysis and Review Development: 50 hours.
  • Pros
    Review Updates: 62 hours.
  • Pros
    Customer Reviews Collection and Processing: 50 hours.

Here are the costs accrued in research, authoring and publication:

  • Pros
    Amount spent on casino deposits and wagering: $700 per month.
  • Pros
    Annual Investment in Devices: $7000 to gather accurate and relevant details for identifying the best new online casino in New Zealand.

Note: There are additional costs for salaries, office maintenance and related overheads.

Casino Testing Methodology

Our casino testing process is made up of various stages, each providing information on a specific aspect of the casino.

Here is a quick rundown of the stages:

Research Stages

Legitimacy and Licencing
Legitimacy and Licencing
  • Collect the casino licence number from the licencing authority’s official database.
  • Check the legitimacy and casino licence in the casino terms.
  • Find official certifications from independent site testers like eCOGRA.
  • Verify the website’s security specifications, like encryption type.
Check the Casino Background
Check the Casino Background
  • Check out the site’s launch year and experience.
  • Get information about the company owning the casino.
  • Find the casino’s sister sites.
User Feedback
User Feedback
  • Collect online casino reviews from Kiwi users.

Data Collection Process

Here are the key areas in the data collection process:

User Experience

User Experience

  • Test how long the registration process takes.
  • Verify the account and note the KYC documents and process.
  • Test navigation on desktop and mobile.
  • Examine the casino apps available and the downloading process.
Game Testing

Game Testing

In order to collect data that has an impact on Kiwi players, NZCasinoClub experts do the following:

  • Test the casino’s most popular games and record the number of games and categories.
  • Play with the minimum and maximum bets for each game category.
  • Check the providers available on the website and how their games perform.
Payment Methods

Payment Methods

We check the following with regards to payments:

  • Test available deposit methods, limits, time, and fees.
  • Cash-out and note withdrawal limits, policies, and processing times.
Customer Support

Customer Support

  • Examine the quality and availability of casino customer support.

Objective Analysis and Review

We have an objective analysis system that compares the casinos we review with competitors to identify areas in which the brand stands out. Each review also evaluates the performance of the casino based on the available industry information, quality criteria, and user experience. We also anonymously create live accounts and undergo the same process as any player, including the KYC check, to provide authentic and reliable insights.

Usability Testing

NZCasinoClub casino club experts test the usability of the online casinos, on the following aspects:

Mobile

Many Kiwi gamblers access casinos using their phones. Therefore, any good casino must be mobile-friendly. Our review team scrolls through each site using mobile devices. We look at the overall interface, how each element appears, how attractive the graphics are and the quality of the gaming experience.

Desktop/Web

Members of our team also browse each website with our computers. It helps them ascertain if the casino interface is player-oriented, easy to navigate and secure. We then explore each of the features provided and take note of any glitches or bugs. Finally, we check the overall graphics and attractiveness of the website.

Apps

Casino apps make it easy for players to enjoy their games on the go. For casinos that have apps, we wish to determine if they offer a good gaming experience to players. We download apps for iOS and Android and play with them to ascertain their quality.

Slot Games Testing

Pokie games make up the largest percentage of titles in most casinos. Our team is keen to know the kind and quality of slots offered. We test a variety of titles from different providers, including classics, progressive jackpots, video slots, megaways, feature buys, and 5-reel titles. Ideally, the best games should be smooth to play, safe and have a variety of features. Finally, we verify payout rates with T&Cs or independent agencies like eCOGRA.

Live Games Testing

We test live dealer games by entering lobbies and making bets. Our members bet with various amounts and check if the set limits are indeed correct. Additionally, we assess the variety of live games and subtypes, such as live roulette, blackjack, and baccarat. It enables us to give in-depth information on each variant.

Deposits and Withdrawals

Our team would like players to know the best methods to transact with. Therefore, we test multiple payment methods by making deposits and withdrawals. We also check the maximum cashout limits and processing times in the T&Cs.

Customer Support Testing

Quality customer service is a key feature when evaluating the suitability of a casino. We evaluate the availability and reliability of support methods like 24/7 live chat and email. Our teams also test pre-registration and VIP support options in casinos that have the option.

Safety

We would also like to know if the casino is fully licenced and is regularly audited. Therefore, we verify gambling licences from regulatory bodies like the Malta Gaming Authority, the UKGC, or the Kahnawake Commission. In the same breath, we check for independent auditor certifications from eCOGRA or iTechLabs.

Testing Devices

Finally, we conduct tests on mobile devices (e.g., iPhone 12 Pro) and laptops (e.g., MacBook Air) to identify glitches or system errors. Additionally, we compare performance and interface differences across devices to ensure user-friendliness. This enables us to recommend or note the best devices to play the casino and determine if its website is user-friendly.

NZCasinoClub Rating System

After the in-depth research and review process, we aggregate scores from each category of the casino to form an overall rating. We do indicate the individual scores for each category to give players a clear picture of what to expect

The 2024 casino ratings from NZCasinoClub are derived from our evaluation of each crucial element of the gambling platform.

Our online casino reviews display our scores for every section, utilising objective criteria to compute these ratings:

 

  • Rating 1/10: Unacceptable - Severe issues, potentially unsafe or untrustworthy.
  • Rating 2/10: Very Poor - Major flaws in multiple areas, not recommended.
  • Rating 3/10: Poor - Significant problems, far below average quality.
  • Rating 4/10: Below Average - Notable shortcomings, needs substantial improvement.
  • Rating 5/10: Average - Meets basic standards but doesn't stand out.
  • Rating 6/10: Above Average - Solid performance with some notable strengths.
  • Rating 7/10: Good - Consistently good quality across most areas.
  • Rating 8/10: Very Good - Excellent in many aspects, minor room for improvement.
  • Rating 9/10: Exceptional - Outstanding quality, exceeds expectations in most areas.
  • Rating 10/10: Perfect - Flawless experience, sets the industry standard.

 

Towards the end of our review process, we make suggestions based on players’ preferences and needs. Here, we help you determine if the casino meets your needs based on what you wish to play or spend. Additionally, we emphasise the areas that the casino under review excels in.

For example, a casino may be good at slots but have few table games. Another one may offer players lots of bonuses but have fewer tournaments. We recommend that you check this area to determine if the said casino excels in the section that meets your preferences or needs.

We are always improving our research processes to give players better quality and more accurate information. Visit our casino and go through various articles to know exactly what we mean by quality reviews.

Our Top NZ Online Casinos April 2025
Get Free Bonuses Weekly!

Get the hottest bonuses delivered straight to your inbox, spam free!